Top 10 Pop-Punk Albums of All Time
Since I started learning about what real music was in about the sixth grade, there has never a more important genre to me than pop punk. Before that, all I listened to was my dad’s music. I was lucky, because my dad has excellent taste in rock and roll and all of those bands that he showed me – Dire Straits, The Eagles, Fleetwood Mac, Boston, etc. – are bands that I still listen to. My dad also showed me Bruce Springsteen, who I consider to be the best musician of all time and my favorite artist ever. But in sixth or seventh grade, my life was changed by New Found Glory, Green Day and Yellowcard.
Since then, I’ve gone through a holy crap-ton of phases. In junior year of high school, I liked a girl who was really into this simple indie stuff, so I got really into indie pop rock-ish music. And in a phase before that, I was really into poppier stuff; there was a time when Forever the Sickest Kids‘ debut full-length was on repeat in my car and I listened to All Time Low‘s So Wrong, It’s Right on a daily basis. For a good amount of my senior year in high school, I was on what I considered at the time to be a “scream-o” binge. During that time I listened to a lot of Chiodos, Scary Kids Scaring Kids, Silverstein, and I’d continue that list but really I don’t want to lose any more street cred than I already have.
When I started college and found my true calling (or whatever) in writing (or whatever I’m doing that resembles writing), I sort of naturally drifted back to pop punk. Like about half of the people in the world, The Wonder Years‘ The Upsides led me to better times. But the music that I discovered in the time before and after the release of The Upsides is just as important. The entire No Sleep/Run for Cover Records scene is something incredible that I consider myself lucky to be somewhat a part of. Of course other labels are in on the action and of course those bands will move upwards and onwards, out of their starter labels to bigger things.
But anyway, the point here is that things begin and end with this genre for me. Call me what you will, it doesn’t bother me. On a typical day, I might listen to Transit‘s Keep This To Yourself when I walk to the bus, Bayside‘s latest release when I’m riding the bus, maybe some of Man Overboard‘s Real Talk if I’m feeling somewhat angsty, or maybe some of Brand New‘s Your Favorite Weapon if I’m feeling nostalgic.
I don’t know how accurate that list actually might be for a typical day of mine, but you get the idea.
Without any further ado, the following is my list of the best pop punk records of all time. Now, I will first make one thing clear: there are albums that have been made that I consider better than some of these records. But this list was made with a heavy dose of personal taste and emotional sentiment, so continue at your own risk, dearest reader, and ready your fingertips for whatever scathing fury you will unleash upon me at the culmination of your reading.
Top 10 Pop-Punk Albums of All Time
10. Yellowcard – Ocean Avenue
9. Thrice - The Artist In The Ambulance
8. Blink-182 - Take Off Your Pants and Jacket
7. Motion City Soundtrack – Commit This To Memory
6. Brand New - Your Favorite Weapon
5. The Wonder Years: The Upsides
I bet most people were wondering where this album would land on my list. It’s quite possible that no album has ever meant as much to me as this one, but when making a list such as this one there is a hodgepodge of things to consider, which is what lowers The Upsides’ ranking a bit. Still though, The Wonder Years are a band that is going to reinvent the scene in 2011 and beyond. _____________________________________________________________
4. Yellowcard: Paper Walls
I fully expect this pick to receive the most outrage. Paper Walls is the pop punk album that every band wanted to write, but never had within themselves. Bands like blink-182 did, with that self-titled record. Paper Walls will forever be Yellowcard’s opus. It’s dark, edgy and ambitious while retaining a ridiculous amount of catchiness.
3. Green Day: Dookie
For the longest time, Green Day and Yellowcard were my favorite bands. Like, probably from sixth to tenth grade. Yellowcard stayed at the top for longer than that while Green Day sort of faded away. But Dookie is something timeless, an album that even non-fans of the genre can love. It’s also a solid pick for those pop-punk purists, who insist that bands like New Found Glory write “easycore” or “happy hardcore” or whatever the genre Nazi will call it. 1994, okay? This was one of the first important albums in the genre, and will always be among my favorite.
2. Blink-182: Enema of the State
Perhaps a pick that is easy to see coming. For most people, it comes down to whether they like Dude Ranch or Enema Of the State more. For me, the real dilemma is whether or not to put Take Off Your Pants and Jacket here instead. But it’s easy to pick Enema because of its singles, it’s strongest tracks. “Dumpweed,” so help me God, is a song I’ll be listening to regularly in 20 years. There isn’t much to say about this record that hasn’t already been said by someone more important than me.
1. New Found Glory: Sticks and Stones
No, I am not kidding you, reader. This is my favorite pop punk album of all time. Is it a cliché pick? Is it an easy pick? I don’t know, you can make up your mind about that. But at the end of the day it’s my pick and it’s never a pick that I have to think about. My favorite album ever? Easy. Bruce Springsteen’s Born to Run. I’m not the guy who goes, “Ughhhh…well you know, I just love so much music, I just can’t really put my finger on one.” Nope. Not that guy. The question of my favorite pop punk album is as easy as my favorite album of all time. From start to finish, there is never a slow moment. Even the songs that get forgotten are phenomenal. Closer “The Story So Far” is my favorite closer on an album in this genre. And something that I consider noteworthy – when people ask me what pop punk is, I play “My Friends Over You” for them before anything else. There’s nary a song I’d rather drunkenly belt out with close friends. So yes, I could talk about each individual track but I won’t, because much like the individual Power Rangers and Neville Longbottom, they are all stronger when they’re put together or given a burst of courage in a tough situation. Such is the end of my list, and I hope you enjoyed read.
More Than Honorable Mention (alphabetically):
Bayside – The Walking Wounded
Northstar – Pollyanna
Set Your Goals – Mutiny!
Sum 41 – Does This Look Infected?
Taking Back Sunday - Tell All Your Friends
Thomas Nassiff is a staff writer for AbsolutePunk.net. He is 20, goes to school at the University of Florida in Gainesville, and enjoys short walks on cement sidewalks and petting Drew Maroon’s hair when he has been drinking a little bit. Like the article? Follow Thomas on twitter! @ThomasNassiff
Comments
-
Nick Jones says:
The list is not that good. I love the wonder years but that album is too new to be considered.
Stay What You Are and Goddamnit are not on here, and Yellowcard gets mentioned twice? Blasphemy.
I don’t see how Thrice is pop punk or Tell All Your Friends.
I really don’t get how you can put TWO blink albums on the list and one of them isn’t Dude Ranch. That cd is perfection.
New Found Glory’s earlier work was also way better than Sticks & Stones. -
Sebastian Fonseca says:
Nice list Drew, my list would definitely be a lot different, but we can definitely agree on Dookie.
Also I really think I’m the only who thinks that the praise The Wonder Years gets, is really undeserved. -
Sebastian Fonseca says:
just realized this was by Thomas Nassiff (should have realized that from the Bruce Springsteen mention), so instead of saying “Nice list Drew” I will say “nice list Thomas”.
-
Jeffrey Nieves says:
Epic fail man. Terrible list. You should change the list to, “My favorite Pop Punk albums of all time.” Honestly, this is awful.
-
Thomas Nassiff says:
What the fuck does it say in the stupid header?
-
Thomas Nassiff says:
That was rude of you, Thomas. Don’t curse at people.
-
Cheyne Delaney says:
it’s ok i think it was warranted
-
-
Mon Uero says:
Top 10 Pop-Punk Albums of All Time. READ
-
Cheyne Delaney says:
As interpreted by Thomas Nassiff. READ
-
-
-
-
Pingback: Bruce Springsteen | Video, Torrent, Downloads | Poodlesnatcher
-
Bret says:
There is absolutely no way yellowcard wrote one of the best pop punk albums of all time, much less two. This is a personal list, and I understand we all have opinions, however, anyone who listens to pop punk and doesn’t include saves the day on their top 10 list just makes me laugh.
-
Thomas Nassiff says:
They’re going to play a bunch of Saves the Day records at my funeral to make everyone bored and sad, so make sure you’re there and you can laugh at my poor, unprivileged corpse because I never liked that band.
-
-
Jeffrey Nieves says:
In small font on top of a picture. Plus, it doesn’t change how bad your list is. Let’s be real, it is really bad. Two Yellowcard albums? No Fallout Boy? ? Sticks and Stones? No TBS?It also doesn’t change the basic precedent of online “top ten lists” is which attempt to at least feign objectivity.
-
Garry Lee says:
He mentioned TBS in his “More Than Honorable Mention” section.
-
“But this list was made with a heavy dose of personal taste and emotional sentiment, so continue at your own risk, dearest reader, and ready your fingertips for whatever scathing fury you will unleash upon me at the culmination of your reading.”
Mentions multiple times that it is an OPINIONATED list. Obvious. Read.
-
Thomas Nassiff says:
You, sir, are not a tool, but an entire toolkit. You can’t call my list bad, it’s my list. It’s MY favorites, not yours. Let’s be real, you are a moron. If you date a girl and I think she’s ugly as balls, I can’t really say anything about that. I mean I could, I could yell and yearn for attention by calling her ugly and saying how could you like that girl? But you’re still going to find her attractive for whatever reason. Have you ever even heard of subjectivity? Did you go to high school?
-
-
Jeffrey Nieves says:
Through Being Cool? The Ataris? NOFX? MXPX? TSL?
-
and surely fall out boy’s first record deserves a mention? and saves the day. the more i think, the more i rage. not sure jawbreaker would classify but since it’s ‘personal’ and TBS do, then why not?
-
Thomas Nassiff says:
You have no idea how happy I am that this list makes you mad. MAKE YOUR OWN LIST. Let out some of that rage, Bruce Banner.
-
-
I would have some of these records on my own list and some I wouldn’t. As others have said, it’s a matter of taste. Blink, Green Day, and Northstar would make my top ten for sure. The big problem I have is the fact that you said BORN TO RUN was your favorite album ever. That’s not even the best Springsteen album. That honor goes to DARKNESS ON THE EDGE OF TOWN That record is epic.
-
Pingback: Punk Dating Websites | AMERICAN SINGLES
-
I agree on alot of the bands here on this list and I know it’s your bands but more in dept honorable mention the movie life, the starting line, self titled new found glory, no early fall out boy, hot rod circuit I mean it must have been difficult to complie this list sure it could have been a top 25 easy
-
Adam Z says:
Good list, people have different views of what pop punk is and different thoughts, they are stupid if they make fun of it.
No The Dangerous Summer though? I feel like that’s right up your alley.
-
Thanks for making this list, as a long term fan of the genre (I’m 30) it’s cool to see your Perspective. Nice list. Here’s mine:
1.new found glory-s/t (Simply the best)
2.saves the day-through being cool
3.brand new-your favorite weapon
4.green day-dookie (got me into the genre, 7th grade)
5.blink-enema (Travis took them to the next level. I had dude ranch first)
6.fall out boy-fuct
7yellowcard-ocean ave/paper walls tie
8.mxpx-life in general
9.cartel-chroma
10.Allister-before the blackout
11.midtown-living wellHonorable mentions:winder years-upsides
SYG-mutiny (too new for me to rank, but they’re real good) -
The hardest thing for me is realizing that most punk genre names have been co-opted. Pop punk, emo…these labels used to mean real bands like The Descendents, Big Drill Car (pop-punk) and Rites of Spring, Embrace (emo). But that’s all done now. Pop punk now means bands that are watered down top 40 bands. It’s really hard to swallow even after all these years. Anyone claiming to like music like on this list would have gotten your ass kicked back in my day. And not in the cool “I was a punk” kind of way. But times have changed. So sad. Gross.
-
There is not one shred of punk in your list… This is a pop list. mu guess is you gathered up handfuls of your hot topic receipts and starting writing down band names… Cause this makes no sense. Seriously though, you should look into pop punk, although judging by the list you made, you may not enjoy it too much…
-
Try listening to the original British/Northern Irish punk bands…none of your aforementioned bands would be playing any style of punk music if it weren’t for the bands/albums listed below-
The Jam-In the City
999-999
Stiff Little Fingers-Inflammable Material
Generation X-Generation X
The Clash-The Clash
Sham 69-That’s Life
The Police-Outlandos D’ Amour
The Buzzcocks-Singles Going Steady
The Undertones-The Undertones
Elvis Costello-This Year’s ModelThough the Police and Elvis Costello were not true punk artists per se’
-
I love tell all your friends.. but still think Where you want to be is my fav. TBS album.. Saves the Day- Through Being cool/ Stay what you are.. The Ataris- Blue Skies.. Broken Hearts. Next 12 Exits.. If I were to choose a Motion City Album it would definitly be I am the Movie.. Say Anything- is a real boy.. classic.. Early November- The Room’s too cold.. And It would be tough to pick one NFG Album.. it’s between S/T and Sticks and Stones.. but Id go w. the self titled album..
Leave a Comment
Mind Equals Blown











matrocksteady says:
April 22, 2011 at 4:50 PM
Fairly standard choices. I dig it. Liked that you picked Paper Walls, it was definitely a bit out of left field, especially since you put it above Ocean Avenue. Rationale for it was solid.
Cool to see you writing outside of ap.net, Thomas.